Mihi videtur ut palea
  • Home
  • About
  • "Mihi videtur ut palea"
  • Motley Thoughts
  • Poetry

Pentecost 15A (Matthew 18:15-20)

8/30/2026

 
At first hearing, this passage sounds like a procedure for settling a quarrel. In one sense it is. But notice where it happens. It presupposes a wrong between two members of the same body — people who have made an informed and voluntary decision to follow Jesus and to live the life he lives. This is not a rule for two strangers who happen to dislike each other. It is a word for the church: for those who have agreed to sit before the presence of God and to let that presence reshape them.

Following Jesus does not make us suddenly righteous. We still act out of the wrong place in ourselves. We still put on a face that is not our own and act from behind it, and when we do, someone gets hurt.

Matthew knows this — which is why he sets this passage where he does. Just before it, Jesus tells of the shepherd who leaves the ninety-nine to go after the one sheep that wandered off (18:12–14). Just after it, Peter asks how many times he must forgive, and Jesus answers: seventy-seven times (18:21–22). The instruction we are about to hear is held between relentless pursuit and limitless forgiveness. Whatever "go and point out the fault" means, it means something that lives inside that bracket. So when I say my reading is not the usual one, understand: I am not reading gentleness into a hard text against its grain. I am reading the frame Matthew built around it.

So hear the first step again: "go and tell him his fault, between the two of you alone." Alone — that is, privately. Not in front of the others. Not somewhere the community can watch him redden. That privacy is not a technicality; it is already mercy. Before anything is resolved, the wrong is named in a room small enough to keep the other person from being shamed.

And it is named. Jesus says "point it out," and that matters. A wrong that is never spoken is a wound left to close over dirt. The silence I am about to describe is not a way to avoid the hard words. It is what makes the hard words survivable.

Because imagine what that private room could become. Two people who have both agreed to sit before God — what if, before the naming, before the apology, they simply sat together in silence? In that silence I can begin to see the face I was wearing when I did the wrong — the one I picked up without noticing and mistook for myself. I feel the guilt, and I should; I did the thing. But there is a difference between guilt and shame. Guilt says, I did something wrong. Shame says, I am something wrong — and that is the lie the silence dissolves. The face I wore is not the face I am. I can set it down.

This, I think, is what Jesus means when he speaks of loosing: "whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven" (18:18). To loose is to untie, to let go. The first thing to loose is the false face I have been binding to myself. And once it is off, there is no shame left in the apology — because I am no longer defending a mask. I am only telling the truth about what it did.

What is left is not some holier face I manufacture to look forgiven. A mask hides a face; I do not need another one. What is left is the unveiled face — the one Paul says beholds God "with unveiled face" and is changed by what it sees (2 Corinthians 3:18). I do not put on Christ the way I put on a mask. A mask hides a face. Christ gives me mine back.

If the two cannot get there alone, Jesus widens the circle — one or two others, then the whole church. But do not hear this as a case moving up through a court. Nothing changes about the medium. What changes is how many people hold you while the truth is told. First one holds you in the silence. Then a few. Then the whole body sits before God together — each person alone in that presence, and all of them together in it — so that the naming and the letting-go happen in a room large enough to catch whoever falls. Without that, "I forgive you" is only a sound. Forgiveness needs somewhere to land.

And if even that does not reach him — "let him be to you as a gentile and a tax collector." We hear that and think: cast him out. But remember who is speaking, and remember the book we are in.

This is the Gospel written under the name of a tax collector (9:9). Its Jesus was mocked as a friend of tax collectors because he would not stop eating with them (9:11; 11:19). To treat someone as a tax collector, in this Gospel, is not to lock the door. It is to do what Jesus did with tax collectors — go to his house, sit at his table, keep pursuing him with a patience that refuses to quit.

And a gentile? This is the Gospel that ends with the risen Jesus sending his followers out to the gentiles, to every nation (28:19). The gentile is not the one shut out. The gentile is the one they are sent toward.

So the person who will not yet drop the mask does not fall off the edge of the church's care. He becomes its mission. He is the one sheep. He is the next dinner.

That is where the escalation was always heading. Not toward the exit. Toward the table.

Pentecost 14A (Matthew 16:21-28)

8/24/2026

 
- Five verses. That is all it takes: In one breath, Jesus calls Simon the rock: "on this rock I will build my church." A few sentences later, to the very same man, he says: "Get behind me, Satan." The same Peter. The rock and the Satan, almost in the same breath.

So what did Peter do to earn that? He loved Jesus. That's all. Jesus says he is going to Jerusalem to suffer and die, and Peter cannot bear it. "God forbid, Lord. This must never happen to you." It is the tenderest sentence in the whole chapter. And it is the one Jesus calls satanic.

Listen to the word Jesus uses. In Greek: "You are a skandalon to me." A stumbling block. An obstacle lying in the road. And then he names exactly what the obstacle is: "You are setting your mind not on the things of God, but on the things of humans." Two little phrases in Greek, set against each other: the things of God, and the things of humans. The whole passage turns on that seam. Hold onto it. We are going to come back to it.

- The self we did not choose: But first, widen out. Jesus says, "If any want to become my followers, let them deny themselves." Before we can ask what it means to deny the self, we have to ask a stranger question: how did you get a self in the first place?

Think about it honestly. You didn't pick the language you first cried out in. The family, the country, the customs handed to you before you could speak. The body you were born into. Your race, your gender, the way all of these get read by other people before you've said a single word. None of it chosen. All of it received.

And here is the trick of it. It does not feel received. It feels like nature. It feels like simply me. These are not costumes we could shrug off in an afternoon. They are laid down in us like sediment, layer on layer, year on year, until they feel like the floor of the world. That depth is not a small thing. That depth is exactly why what comes next is so dangerous, and why it is the work of a lifetime and not a weekend project.

- To deny is not to hate: "Deny yourself." If you have ever been told you are worthless, that phrase can sound like more of the same. So let me say clearly what it is not. To deny the self is not to hate the self. It is not self-erasure.

There is an old word for it. The writer Iris Murdoch called it unselfing. Not destroying who you are. Loosening your grip on it. Because the problem was never that you have a self. The problem is that we get fused to it. Welded to one version of who we are, defending it as if our life depended on it.

To deny yourself is to un-fuse. To let the word self become a verb again, a way of responding, moment by moment, instead of a fixed thing you have to guard. Free enough to choose, in each situation, what actually serves the long good of yourself and others. Free enough to take up, and free enough to set down.

Here is where I have to be careful, because this can be heard wrongly. To be locked into a single identity, even a good one, even a true one, is to lose that freedom to respond. But the danger is never the identity itself. The danger is the fusion: when the identity is holding you, instead of you holding it, so that you can no longer even ask, "What does love actually require of me right here?" and answer freely.

And it costs differently for different people. For some, whose identity has been a fortress, this un-fusing is pure release. For others, whose identity has been a wound, simply naming who they are is the first thing that lets them be heard at all. The gospel does not flatten that difference. But it points all of us the same direction: toward a self free enough to choose the skillful thing.

- How Jesus does it, from the inside: Now watch Jesus do this himself. And notice how. He does not do it by leaving his people. He does not treat his tradition as a cage to break out of. He says it plainly elsewhere: "I have not come to abolish the law, but to fulfill it." He works from the inside: as a Jew going deeper into his own inheritance than the guardians of it were willing to go. When they cling to sacrifice, he quotes their own prophets back to them: "I desire mercy, not sacrifice." When they major in the small rules, he reaches past them to the weightier things: justice, mercy, faithfulness. He is not throwing the tradition away. He is turning it all the way up.

And that is what gets you killed. Not escaping your people, but deepening their faith past what the powerful can tolerate. So his cross is not bad luck falling on him from outside. His cross is this work. The cost of setting his mind wholly on the things of God, while everyone who loves him begs him to be reasonable.

- The obstacle wears the face of love: Which brings us back to Peter. Because Peter is us. Here is the hardest truth in this whole passage. The obstacle to God's will did not show up as an enemy. It showed up as love. As common sense. As "Lord, spare yourself." The stumbling block was Peter's own care.

This is why we so rarely catch the obstacle in ourselves. It never announces itself as the enemy. It arrives sounding like wisdom. Like prudence. Like the voice of the people who love us most.

So ask yourself, honestly: could you recognize, right now, the one thing in you that stands most in the way of God? Most likely not. Not because we are foolish. Because it is wearing the face we trust.

So how? Begin with presence: Then here is the honest question. I can want to deny myself. I can want to un-fuse, to take up my cross. But if the obstacle looks like love, then trying harder will only defend it. My own effort will guard the very thing that needs to loosen. So how do we even begin?

We do not begin by working on ourselves. We begin by placing ourselves in the presence of God. That is the first move, and there is no move before it. Not analysis. Presence.

And I have to be honest about one phrase before we go there. Jesus says, "Those who lose their life for my sake will find it." It would be easy to hear that as loyalty to a leader: join his team, follow his program. I do not think that is it. When Jesus says "for my sake," he is not pointing to himself as a personality to be admired. He is the one so completely open to the breath of God that to lose yourself into him is to lose yourself into that breath. "For my sake" is not allegiance. It is participation in the pneuma, the Spirit, the very breath of God that moves through him without obstruction. To lose your life for his sake is to let that same breath begin to move through you.

- The prayer that is breath: And that, at last, gives us something we can actually do. With our bodies. In Greek, one word, pneuma, means both breath and Spirit. And close beside it, anemos, wind. The breath in your chest. The wind moving over the water at the beginning of creation. The Spirit brooding over the deep. One word. One movement.

So the prayer I want to leave you with is not made of words. It is made of breath. I call it “embodied prayer.” You sit. And you attend to your breathing, not forcing it, but giving the body what it needs in that moment. Sometimes a fuller breath, to wake you. Sometimes a longer, slower breath, to quiet you. And you let the breathing itself become the prayer. You align your small breath to the great Breath that is already here, that was here before you sat down, that asks nothing of you, that is available in every place and every hour.

You do not deconstruct yourself by force. You breathe, in the presence of God, and you let the presence do what your effort never could. And slowly, in that breath, the fused self begins to loosen. The obstacle that wore the face of love begins, quietly, to show its true face. And the cross that is actually yours, not borrowed, not imposed, but yours, becomes something you can finally see. And pick up. And carry.

That is the work of a lifetime. It begins with one breath, taken in the presence of God.

Pentecost 13A (Matthew 16:13–20)

8/21/2026

 
Matthew 16 is one of the most quoted passages in the history of the Church, and one of the most contested. "You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church." "I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven." From these few lines an entire architecture has been built — Peter as the first Pope, the keys as his possession to hand down, the Church as the gate you must pass through to reach the kingdom of God. It has been used theologically. It has been used politically. Whole hierarchies stand on it.

And around it grows a familiar conversation. Apostolic succession. Right lineage. Orthodoxy. Who holds the keys, who received them from whom, who stands in the unbroken chain. I want to say plainly what I actually think: this conversation does not change a single life. It never has. It is a trap, and it is mostly nonsense — a fight over the deed to a house while no one bothers to live in it. So let us not get caught there.

Let me read the passage again, from the inside this time.

What is Peter actually confessing? "You are the Christ, the Son of the living God." Notice what he is not doing. He is not setting Jesus above himself to be admired from a distance. He is naming a relationship — Son of the living God. And if Jesus is the Son of the living God, then what Jesus opens to us, what he keeps calling the kingdom of God, is that we too are children of that same living God through him. The confession is not really about Jesus' status. It is about ours.

I have never been convinced that a man like Jesus wanted to be worshipped. Remember when someone calls him "good teacher," and he stops them — "Why do you call me good? No one is good but God alone." He deflects. He points past himself. Again and again he moves the attention off his own person and toward the Father, toward the presence of God that he insists is near, is at hand, is within you. That is the whole thrust of his ministry. The kingdom of God is not a territory you enter after death or after joining the right institution. It is a presence you sense, here, now.

And here is the line everyone hurries past on their way to the keys. Jesus turns to Peter and says: "Flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my Father in heaven." Sit with that phrase — flesh and blood — because it is doing two things at once, and I do not want to lose either one.

In one sense, flesh and blood means the bloodline. Inheritance. Pedigree. The estate handed down from father to son, the succession that later generations would fight over and build their politics on. And Jesus refuses it, flatly: the revelation did not reach Peter that way. It was not passed down like property. The one passage weaponized for centuries to defend lineage and office contains, at its very heart, a refusal of lineage. The text dismantles the reading imposed on it.

But flesh and blood means something else too, and this I will not negate. Flesh and blood is the body. It is where God's presence is actually felt — sensed, breathed, lived. When the Father's revelation comes, it does not land in some bodiless mind hovering above the world. It lands in Peter — a man, standing there, breathing. The presence of God is an embodied experience or it is nothing; the body is the only place any of us has ever known anything at all. So the phrase turns on itself, and beautifully. God's presence is not given by flesh and blood, as if it were inherited property — and yet it is only ever known in flesh and blood, in this living, sensing body. What Jesus rejects is flesh and blood as bloodline. What he relies on is flesh and blood as the place the Father is felt.

So what is the rock? Not an office. Not a man's name. Not a chain of ordinations. The rock is that inner presence of God, sensed and known in the flesh, from within — the very thing Peter had just touched when he spoke. Paul, the apostle, calls this same movement the renewing of the mind: "Be transformed by the renewing of your mind." That inner experience is not sealed in the first century. It is still available. It is available to you this morning.

How do we come to it? The same one thing Jesus keeps returning to. Silence. Meditation. Contemplation. The breath. And notice — not one of these leaves the body behind. The breath is flesh and blood. Sitting in stillness is the body attending. This is not a flight out of the flesh into some purer spirit; it is the flesh grown quiet enough to sense what has been present in it all along. Not more information, not a better argument, not a higher rung on the ladder — just the patient turning inward, in the body, until we sense what is already there.

And because it comes from the Father and not from flesh and blood, it belongs to no tribe. This is what Jesus stands against with his whole life. No Jew, no Greek. No slave, no free. No male, no female. The keys of the kingdom are handed to whoever senses God's presence within — and they are handed, just as freely, to everyone else. The keys were never a family heirloom. They were never anyone's to hoard.

So the question comes back to us. Do you sense it? Not do you believe the right things, not can you recite the right lineage — do you actually sense the presence of God, alive, within you? Is your spiritual life built on that unshaken rock, or on something borrowed and secondhand?

And I have to ask it of us together. Is Trinity Allendale built on this rock? We say we want the church to grow. But there is no growing a church whose people have not first found this rock in their own lives. Everything else is scaffolding around an empty center.

This is why I want, more than anything, to found this rock with you in the time I have here — until the end of January. That is my real goal among you. Not programs, not numbers. This. Whether I succeed at this will decide whether anything real can begin. So let us begin at the beginning: in silence, in the breath, in the presence of God that flesh and blood cannot give and cannot take away.

Pentecost 12A (Matthew 15:21-28)

8/14/2026

 
​It is always a little shocking to encounter Jesus in today's Gospel. He seems abrupt, harsh, even rude to this desperate mother. We hear his words and wonder: Why would he treat her this way?

Ordinarily, I would not feel the need to defend anyone. In chaplaincy training, we learn not to explain people away or excuse their behavior, but to receive them as they are. Yet I find myself wanting to defend Jesus here. For someone whose very breath is prayer itself, it seems almost harder to imagine him deliberately wounding another person. I assume that something else is happening beneath the surface. I assume that he has a deeper purpose, even at the cost of appearing harsh.

To understand this story, we need to remember the world Jesus lived in.

Throughout his ministry, Jesus is constantly arguing with religious authorities and challenging the assumptions that structure religious life. Eventually, those conflicts lead to his arrest and crucifixion. At the center of many of these disputes is a single question: What makes a person clean or unclean?

The world of Jesus' time was organized around these categories. Gentiles were unclean. The sick were unclean. Women during menstruation were unclean. Corpses were unclean. Human beings were divided according to systems of purity and exclusion.

In the passage immediately preceding this story, Jesus has already challenged that entire framework. He teaches that what defiles a person is not what enters from outside but what comes forth from within. The issue is not ritual purity but the condition of the heart.

Then comes this Canaanite woman. By every conventional standard, she is unclean. She is a Gentile. An outsider. Someone who does not belong. When she approaches Jesus, the disciples say, "Send her away, for she keeps shouting after us." Jesus replies, "I was sent only to the lost sheep of the house of Israel."

Still she persists. "Lord, help me." Then comes the most difficult line of all: "It is not fair to take the children's food and throw it to the dogs."

At first glance, Jesus appears to be reproducing the very exclusion he has spent his ministry opposing. But perhaps what we see here is a mirror. He voices exactly what the religious authorities of his day would have thought. Send her away. She does not belong. She is not one of us. She is unworthy of God's concern.

The woman is treated not merely as an outsider but as a dog. In the social and religious imagination of the time, this would not have been shocking. This was simply how the unclean were regarded. From the perspective of the dominant religious system, Jesus is doing what is expected. Nothing appears wrong.

Yet the woman refuses to disappear. She refuses to accept the story that has been imposed upon her.

She answers: "Yes, Lord, yet even the dogs eat the crumbs that fall from their masters' table." There is nothing defensive in her response. No wounded pride. No demand for recognition. No struggle for status. Her ego has become irrelevant before her love for her daughter. She comes empty-handed and empty of herself. And it is at this point that Jesus finally reveals what he truly sees. "Woman, great is your faith! Let it be done for you as you wish."

The categories collapse. The distinction between clean and unclean disappears. The outsider becomes the model of faith. What matters is not bloodline, status, religious identity, or social location. What matters is the heart. The woman's faith is a heart purified of self-concern, pride, and ego. She stands before God with nothing left to defend. In that emptiness, healing becomes possible.

This Gospel speaks powerfully to our own time. We may not use the language of clean and unclean, but we continue to construct categories that divide human beings. We label one another. We sort people into groups. We decide who matters and who does not. We cling to identities that make us feel secure, important, or superior.

We learn what neighborhood someone comes from and assume what kind of person they must be. We look at a person's job title and unconsciously treat them with more or less respect. We encounter someone who is homeless and reduce them to that one fact about their life. We dismiss someone because of their political affiliation before we have even listened to them. We label people by race, nationality, immigration status, religion, social class, or education and then relate more to the label than to the person. We create insiders and outsiders in our workplaces, churches, schools, and even our families.

But these categories do not only divide us from one another. We turn them inward. The same machinery that sorts others into clean and unclean, worthy and unworthy, we quietly apply to ourselves.

We compare. We measure ourselves against everyone we meet — their bodies, their careers, their marriages, their children, even their faith. We notice who seems ahead and who seems behind, and we place ourselves somewhere on that ladder. When we imagine ourselves above, we feel a secret pride. When we imagine ourselves below, we feel shame, inadequacy, and sometimes something closer to self-hatred.

We look in the mirror and see only what we lack. We rehearse our failures. We decide that we are not enough — not successful enough, not holy enough, not worthy enough to be loved. We become at once the judge and the accused, and we pronounce ourselves unclean.

This too is a kind of exclusion. We cast ourselves out. We refuse to receive our own selves as they are, just as we refuse to receive the stranger.

And notice: pride and self-hatred are not opposites. They are the same act. Both keep the self at the center. Both are the ego still measuring, still comparing, still anxious about its standing. This is why the Canaanite woman is free of both. When she is called a dog, she does not collapse into shame; when she answers, she does not defend her wounded pride. She has simply stopped measuring herself. To come empty-handed and empty of self is to be free not only of our verdicts about others, but of the endless verdict we pass upon ourselves.

Human history repeatedly returns to these distinctions: insider and outsider, superior and inferior, worthy and unworthy. In that sense, we are not so different from those who lived in Jesus' day.

The challenge of discipleship is to see beyond these constructs, in others and in ourselves — to encounter the face of our neighbor as they truly are, and to receive our own face with the same mercy we owe the stranger. And that transformation begins in prayer.

In silent prayer, the breath itself becomes prayer. We gradually loosen our attachment to the names, labels, and identities that organize our world. We return, in a sense, to the beginning of creation. Before anything was named, before God said, "Let there be light," the Spirit of God hovered over the waters. There was only the divine breath moving over the deep.

There we encounter a kind of holy chaos, a place before our categories and distinctions, before all the social constructs that shape how we see others and ourselves. We allow these structures to die. The false self, built from labels and attachments, begins to dissolve. This is a kind of death. But it is not the end.

For through Christ, through the Breath of God, we are created anew. "Let there be light." Out of emptiness comes illumination. Out of surrender comes resurrection. Out of the death of the false self comes the life of Christ. This is the faith of the Canaanite woman. It is the faith that sees beyond appearances. The faith that empties itself. The faith that receives even crumbs as grace.

And it is this faith that can transform crumbs from the table into the very Body of Christ.

Pentecost 11A (Matthew 14:22–33)

8/7/2026

 
​If there is a goal worth accomplishing, one thing is required above all: to be single-minded. Today's gospel gives us three glimpses of what that looks like. And I would say, metaphorically, that the Christian life is like walking on water. We have heard this story so many times — Jesus walking on the water. But for it to matter to us, it has to say something that touches our own lives.

For me, the most interesting part of the story is not Jesus walking on the water. What I find really fascinating is his prayer life. He goes up the mountain alone to pray. We are not told when he first withdrew, but it was at least evening, and he stayed there, alone, until early morning. I wonder what he prayed about, and how. When we think of prayer, we usually imagine talking to God, saying many words. St. Paul tells us to "pray without ceasing." How could that be possible? I don't think most of us can pray even an hour for ourselves — and I don't believe we are that narcissistic.

So here is my hypothesis. I think Jesus prayed in silence. He prayed according to the Spirit, according to the Breath of God. He placed himself in God's presence and let his own breath fall into rhythm with the breath of God.

There is an old story that has always helped me imagine what that might be like. It comes from nineteenth-century Russia, from an anonymous little book called The Way of a Pilgrim. It begins with a man walking into a church, where he hears the very words of Paul read aloud: pray without ceasing. And he is stopped cold by the same question we just asked — how is that even possible? How can anyone pray in every moment, through work and weariness and the ordinary storms of a day? He cannot let the question go. So he sets out, wandering across Russia with a staff in his hand, asking everyone he meets how a person could pray without ceasing — and never getting an answer that satisfies him. At last he finds an old spiritual father, who tells him the secret is not more words. It is breath. He teaches him a short prayer and shows him to let it ride on his breathing — drawn in, released, drawn in, released — until one day the prayer slips down from his lips into his heart and begins to say itself. It goes on while he walks, while he eats, even while he sleeps. The praying no longer depends on his effort. His breath has become prayer.

That, I think, is what Jesus was doing on the mountain through the whole long night. Not many words. Breath aligned with the Breath of God, until the two could hardly be told apart.

Meanwhile, his friends in the boat were facing a different kind of breath — a strong wind against them, raising the waves, shaking the boat. And notice: this is a different wind altogether. Not the breath that rises from within and comes from God, but a wind that blows in from outside, with its source somewhere out beyond us, ungovernable, answering to no one. One breath indwells you. The other simply befalls you. The whole of the Christian life, I sometimes think, is learning which of the two you will let set your rhythm.

Into that storm, Jesus walks toward his friends. I imagine him carrying his own inner wind — his breath, still attuned to the Breath of God — and so unafraid of the wind outside. And when Peter cannot get past his fear, Jesus calls him out onto the water. As long as Peter keeps his eyes on Jesus, he walks. In that moment he is single-minded. His breath, we might say, has found the same rhythm. But the instant he notices the strong wind — the instant that outer wind, rather than the inner one, becomes the thing he is breathing to — he loses his focus and begins to sink.

And then comes Jesus' hand.

Three glimpses, then, of what it means to be single-minded. First, Jesus' prayer — the solitude that lets him cross the water while everything around him rages, because his breath is set to God's. Second, our own focus: to keep our eyes on Jesus, and above all on the way he prays and breathes, because his breath and ours are meant to be one breath. And like the pilgrim, we do not begin as masters of it; we begin as seekers who have only heard the words and don't yet know how. And third — the glimpse that keeps single-mindedness from hardening into anxious striving — when we do lose our focus and begin to sink, it is alright. There is always the grace of a hand reaching toward us. We take hold of it, catch our breath, and try to walk again. As Samuel Beckett wrote: "Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better."

Pentecost 10A (Matthew 14:13-21)

8/1/2026

 
Today's Gospel is one of the most familiar stories in the New Testament: Jesus feeding more than five thousand people with five loaves and two fish. Because we know the story so well, it is easy to become fascinated by the miracle itself. How did it happen? How were so many people fed? What exactly took place? 
But perhaps the Gospel invites us to look somewhere else.
 
In fact, Jesus is not the first person in Scripture to feed a multitude with a small amount of food. In the Second Book of Kings, the prophet Elisha fed a hundred people with twenty barley loaves. When his servant protested that there was not enough food, Elisha replied, "Give it to the people and let them eat, for thus says the Lord, 'They shall eat and have some left'" (2 Kings 4:42-44). The people ate, and there was food left over.
 
Those who knew the Scriptures would have recognized the echo. Matthew is not simply reporting an extraordinary event. He is showing us who Jesus is. What God did through Elisha, God is now doing through Jesus in an even greater way.
 
Yet even that is not the deepest point. The Gospel begins by telling us that Jesus withdrew to a deserted place. The setting matters. A deserted place represents human helplessness. There are no resources. There is no food. There is no easy solution. Many of us know what it is like to stand in such a deserted place. Sometimes the scarcity is material. We lack money, time, energy, or support. Sometimes it is deeper than that. We may actually have resources, skills, and opportunities, yet still feel powerless to change a difficult situation. We may have all the tools and yet remain unable to heal a relationship, overcome grief, ease loneliness, or remove suffering.
 
The deserted place is wherever we encounter our limits. The crowd in today's Gospel stands in that place of scarcity. The disciples see only the problem and tell Jesus to send the people away. But Jesus answers with a command that is shocking in its simplicity: "You give them something to eat."
 
Not someone else. Not later. Not when you have more. You.
 
The disciples immediately look at what they have and conclude that it isn't enough. Five loaves. Two fish. Nothing compared to the need before them. But perhaps that is precisely where discipleship begins. Because those five loaves and two fish are a symbol of us.


When we come before Christ, we often bring what seems inadequate. Our time feels limited. Our patience feels exhausted. Our compassion feels depleted. Our gifts seem too small for the needs around us. Yet Jesus does not ask for what we do not have. He asks for what we do have. He asks for ourselves. Not merely our money, our talents, or our accomplishments, but our very selves. Our presence. Our kindness. Our attention. Our willingness to stand with another person. Our virtues. Our love. And not our idealized selves.
 
Not the version of ourselves we hope to become. But who we are right now. In all our limitations and imperfections. That is what the disciples place into Jesus' hands. That is what we place into his hands. Notice what Jesus does next. He takes the loaves. He looks up to heaven. He blesses them. He breaks them. And he gives them away.
 
The language should sound familiar. It is the language of the Eucharist. Every time we gather at this altar, we bring bread and wine. But in a deeper sense, we bring ourselves. We place upon the altar all that we are and all that we shall become.


We do not bring perfect lives. We bring our joys and failures, our strengths and weaknesses, our hopes and disappointments. And Christ receives them. He blesses them. He transforms them.
 
The transformation we witness at this altar is not only the transformation of bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Christ. It is also the transformation of those who offer themselves. We are taken, blessed, broken, and shared for the life of the world.
 
The miracle of the Gospel is not only that bread multiplies. The greater miracle is that ordinary people become signs of God's compassion. Because even if five thousand people are fed today, they will be hungry again tomorrow. Physical hunger always returns. 


But compassion nourishes differently. A kind word can sustain a wounded heart. A faithful presence can carry someone through grief. An act of mercy can restore hope. The food Christ gives is ultimately himself, and through him we become nourishment for others.
 
In a few moments, we will come forward to receive Communion. We will receive the One who fed the crowd in the wilderness and who still feeds us today. And then, strengthened by that gift, we will be sent back into the world's deserted places.
 
Not because we have enough. But because Christ is enough. And perhaps we can make the words of the post-Communion prayer our own: "Our hands are empty, but you fill them."
 

    Paul

    "...lift up your love to that cloud [of unknowing]...let God draw your love up to that cloud...through the help of his grace, to forget every other thing."
    ​
    - The Cloud of Unknowing

    Archives

    November 2026
    October 2026
    September 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    July 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    October 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • About
  • "Mihi videtur ut palea"
  • Motley Thoughts
  • Poetry